The Fine Line Between Listeners Spamming Or Spinning Your Music

No Soliciting Sign

Music?

I had another piece of writing in mind for this evening, until I made the pleasurable mistake of opening up the latest Lefsetz Letter before writing. Rather than staying my course, I thought I’d change tack, fulfill one of my three words for 2013, and ‘react’.

You might not like what Bob Lefsetz has to say, but you’ll defend to the death his right to say it when the passion bleeds through in his every missive. To wit…

SPAM: No one is going to listen to your music because you sent them an e-mail, tweet or Facebook link. Hope this effort makes you feel good, because it’s worthless.

Spinning Music vs. Spamming Music

Not all spam is created equal.

In fact, any honest marketer – not an oxymoron, for any smart arses reading – knows the pain of seeing just one ‘Marked as spam’ check in in their campaign report numbers. A painstakingly developed opt-in e-mail list, combined with a true desire to update people on something in which they’ve previously shown an interest, is still one of the most important tools in your music marketing kit, no matter what sweeping statements you read to the contrary.

Beyond that, there are certainly many ways of communicating on Facebook and Twitter that will grate on many people’s last nerve. But to extend that to all tweets and Facebook links being spam is to point to Mitt Romney and call him Mr President… not of this reality.

A personally crafted message to a listener espousing tastes similar to your style of music is far more a caring act than a callous one. Describing your lovingly crafted, finely honed new track to your Facebook community and asking them to share, if it moves them to do so, is opening a doorway and gently ushering new listeners into your home, not jamming a foot in the door of their home and feverishly waving a set of headphones about their face.

The spectrum runs from unwelcome to warmly welcomed, infuriating to ingratiating. People know spam, meaning they also know what it isn’t and will not summarily dismiss everything unexpected as such. That is, apart from those frustrating few in the aforementioned marketing reports… is it so hard to use the ‘unsubscribe’ option, really?

I digress.

 

Know Your Audience Know You

The key here is familiarity. Your prospective listener needs to know you, or at least understand that you are attempting to personally know them, in order to elevate your approach from spam to a spin of your song. 

How do you achieve this?

Only practice opt-in e-mail marketing, preferably segmented for relevance to specific sets of your audience.

Set up listening stations to spot fans of similar styles, explore their web presence to see what they’re listening to or subjects that they’re interested in, then recommend the most suitable song you have for them with a brief explanation.

Become a part of online communities that fit with your music and subject matter,

Write your own self-hosted content, attracting readers and comments to your website where you can build a closer relationship with them.

Or one hundred other steps that involve a personal connection and an open the door for willing new listeners to check out your music. Recent examples for me include Twitter conversations with Brooklyn’s Sojourn Society and Nashville’s Red Measure, both unsolicited but neither of which felt like an intrusion, due to the nature of the approach.

Honest. Personal. Spam factor zero.

Spamalot?

My feeling is that the original point is more nuanced than the spam conclusion asserts, but it raises the valid question that all artists should ask ahead of that next e-mail update or Twitter DM: Are you spamming or connecting?

How can you change the way you approach potential fans this year to make the desire to listen to your music more of a personal thank you than an obligation?

Music Piracy & the Profit Tipping Point

Music Piracy FlagSome significant data were released last week by the (suddenly very visible) music reporting service, MusicMetric.

Significant, in this case, equates to over 400 million instances of illegally downloaded music around the world during the first six months of 2012.

Disaster.

Crisis.

Death of music. 

And yet…

Of Piracy & Profiteering

What most struck me about this report is that the headline artists, those most downloaded in any given country, aren’t of the old guard. From Drake in the US, Ed Sheeran in the UK, and the largely unknown Billy Van in a number of other countries, all are musicians who have risen to prominence in the last few years. [Read more...]

Beck, Publicity and the Continuing Quest For a New Music Paradigm

Music opinions on the internet. You're always wrong.Firestorms flare up that much quicker online…

No sooner had Beck, iconic artist and poster boy for my “slacker generation”, announced plans to release his next album as sheet music only, than had the idea been inflated, exclaimed, and shot down. Indeed, before many of us had taken the time to digest and explore the idea, the curiously polarizing force of the Internet jury had processed its conceptual merits and delivered a typically inconclusive verdict.

But the clarity was delivered, as it so often is, by de facto industry watchdog Bob Lefsetz in his daily missive. Four words was all it took:

“It’s a publicity stunt.”

[Read more...]

Marketing Music: Past, Present, and Future

 

Think about music differently

Image Source: FrikiPix.com

This business of music… it troubles me. 

Not for the age old tension between artistic endeavor and monetary gain (which has troubled me for decades) but for the current lack of invention in delivering music to the masses.

At a time when digital channels open up routes to an audience for almost every conceivable genre, we see ever more artists falling back on the tried and trusted promotional routines of the boom years, flogging them to within an inch of their life for increasingly diminishing returns.

If something is irreparably broken, there comes a time to break down and replace it, rather than patching up another hole and convincing oneself that it will hold out for another passage of use. In some cases, the same applies to an entire business model.

 

“Every act of creation is, first of all, an act of destruction.”

~ Pablo Picasso

 

Creators Lacking Creativity

For an industry that thrives on the creative spark and connecting with its audience, there is a distinct lack of creativity when it comes to actually marketing music to people. From tired album release cycles to sweeping dismissals of digital business models, the record industry of the 21st century clings doggedly to the practices of decades ago.

Musicians must now apply the same freedom of thought that powers their art to the marketing of their music. 

There are almost no limits now to what you can attempt, in terms of releasing your music and encouraging people to buy into your work with cold, hard cash. Financial constraints may always apply but everything else is up for grabs. Free platforms, publicity, and free access to people have opened up the doors of opportunity, with the biggest decision being which ones to select and where to spend the majority of your most valuable resource, time.

 

The Past

In the past, a record label held sway over almost every aspect of marketing your music. With distribution of physical product and limited media channels being the main concerns of disseminating music efficiently to fans around the world, getting signed to a label was at the core of every artist’s career plan.

No longer. Most labels are now  the very epitome of the problem at the heart of the music industry; that same unwillingness to accept that the ‘golden age’ of $15+ albums and radio play payola is dead and gone. Not to discount the labels that do seek out innovative new models, which I warmly applaud, but any look at the latest reformed act from those halcyon days, being dragged out for one last milking in the cash cow shed, will bear out the continued focus of mid/major record companies on music marketing past.

That’s the past. And partially the present, which is a frustratingly sullen plod towards the inevitability of a digital music market place, hamstrung at almost every turn by those seeking to turn back the clock. A transition phase that is agonizingly – tantalizingly? – fluctuating between business models old and new. 

 

The Future

What interests me most is where we can take the release, marketing, and enjoyment of music in the years to come. Let those clinging to the past wallow in declining sales of physical and increasingly ineffective marketing campaigns. As they sink, let us focus our efforts on innovating.

Innovation means improvement. It means introducing better ways of working, through creative thought and testing out ideas. Some will fail, some will be of moderate success. Here and there, though, an idea will be a runaway success and forge a new path for other musicians to follow, like the massive exposure for Daria Musk with her Google+ concerts or Amanda Palmer’s Kickstarter millions.

Yes yes, I know, talk is cheap. Everything I have written thus far is purely conceptual and lacks any practical, actionable advice. Which is why I will now be dedicating every Monday to ‘Music Marketing Matters’ , a series of posts in which I’ll focus on one idea that you can apply to marketing your music, in a way that will help you stand out from the crowd.

I can’t promise success.

I can’t promise a step by step guide to implementing every part of the thoughts that we’ll unpack.

I can promise ideas that will stimulate discussion and help us to move music marketing forward, together.

So jump on the e-mail subscription option to the top left of the page here and we’ll get the ideas rolling from next week. Let me know in the comments if you have an idea you’d like me to spend some time exploring.

Artist Answers: How Do I Propel My Kickstarter Project Funding?

Lynette Music: Funding debut album via Kickstarter

Photo Credit: Emma Rodrigues (click pic for site)

Artist Answers’ is a weekly feature that will help to deliver one of my three guide words for this year: Serve. I ask some like-minded creative types for their most burning new media questions, then set about providing some insight into the topics it raises.

This week, Parisian-based pop/folk (polk?!) artist Lynette jumps into the fray with a detailed question about Kickstarter campaigns. Currently in the last few days of a campaign on the platform, to fund recording of her debut album – you can listen to her music here and, if you dig, back the campaign here – Lynette asks the following:

“We started our Kickstarter campaign at the same time as a couple of other similar music projects and  noticed that one, with the same $25K target, met their goal sooner than we have. We have 1000+ Facebook “likes” to our Kickstarter page, while this particular project just cleared 800.  With what looks like more Facebook exposure, how could we translate that awareness into the $1-$50 donor level participation?”

 

Levels & Layers

As with the fluffy adage about a snowflake, no two Kickstarter campaigns are exactly alike. At least, they shouldn’t be, if the artist is truly seeking to build the project around their own particular fans and the community that they represent. That said, it can be more difficult to distinguish campaigns, especially those related to music, at the lower levels of rewards.

One of the crucial factors is to layer rewards so that each one offers something just a little sweeter than the last. Find the balance between having too many, which can overload a potential backer (paralysis by analysis), and creating enough to suit a number of single and  double digit level backers. The difference between just $10-15 is larger than it seems in this region, so be sure to throw in neat flourishes that will encourage and excite your backers.

Above all, focus on injecting these levels of your campaign with fun and making it accessible to all who wish to support you. Focus on the “every pledge counts!” mantra and show that you value each reward, by weaving some of your (soon to be) famed creativity into each level.

Some examples of neat little extras at these lower levels, that can be achieved with minimal expense to yourself, might include:

  • Handwritten, personalized thank you notes,
  • A link to their web presence and thanks for donating,
  • A blog post on your site, about or including the backer,
  • Smaller merchandise items, such as stickers, tattoos, pins, drink koozies etc,
  • Oddball random items of your own that are limited in number…song notes, guitar picks…I know someone who gave away socks used in the update video…. (you know who you are ;-)

 

Let the Music Play…

Of course, in all of the excitement about personalized rewards and creative merchandise, it can be easy to forget about the music.

Don’t! 

Your music is the crucial element of these lower reward levels, as it will be the core of what draws people in to support you. Plan to weave as many of your songs as possible into the fabric of your campaign video, project updates, social network promotions, and, of course, the end reward outputs.

Some additional thoughts:

  • At the very entry level rewards, up to $10, find ways to include perhaps a song or some advance streaming, so that not only those that pledge at the full album reward levels are included in the musical side,
  • Remember that you can send exclusive updates to just the project backers, something that you can communicate in the reward levels, so those who have not yet pledged understand that they get the inside track on the development of your songs once they back you,
  • Including exclusive previews of music can be exciting to media outlets such as blogs or local press, furthering your reach into their audiences and potentially bringing in curious new listeners, willing to back at the lower levels to explore further,
  • Your existing fans will likely pledge at a level that gets them the full album, regardless of the lower rewards. This effectively acts as a pre-order facility. Newer listeners, perhaps even first timers, however, often need an easier entry point. This  means staggering the music you have available so that they can listen to some for free, get on board, then commit at whichever reward point gets them the music they desire,
  • Also remember that once someone pledges, you have them on your updates list and they can be reached with new music, notifications, and any new rewards that you choose to add. This can be a useful way to bring new listeners into the fold, then persuade them to a larger pledge as their relationship with you and and your music develops.

A Note on Facebook

Facebook Music

Although the exposure that Facebook likes bring on a Kickstarter page is a valuable sharing resource, it appears only as a link on their Facebook Timeline  and the News Feed of their friends. Even visibility of the latter is questionable, given Facebook’s limiting EdgeRank algorithm (more on that here) and the clutter that we all wade through in our feeds nowadays.

Therefore, you should encourage fans to share the project and its page on Facebook and other social media, but not at the expense of the campaign content, which is what will ultimately sell the visitor on backing your project.

For greater reach and traction via Facebook, encourage your closest fans to post about why they have pledged, talk about their favorite aspects of your music, why they are anticipating the new songs…anything that communicates the passion and content acts as a better call to action than a simple ‘like and link’.

And Your Good Self?

Have you successfully funded your own artist project on Kickstarter? What kind of rewards did you offer at the $1-$50 levels to excite fans?

And fans, do you have any advice on what most attracts you to back a Kickstarter campaign? Have you seen artists doing anything especially creative at these levels?

What do you think of the reward levels on Lynette’s campaign?

As always, your input is greatly appreciated! 
Google+