Tag Archives: Beyoncé

U2 and the End of Push Marketing in Music

Ladies and gentlemen, we have reached the nadir. Push marketing of music can go no lower.

Last week U2 and Apple, under cover of hype, conspired to Like Santa, if he chose to deliver only one gift to everyone, regardless of the diversity of their pleading letters.

Listeners get new music. Apple gets renewed audio impetus. U2 gets global exposure. Win-win-win, no?

No.

U2 CD collection
Image Credit: Phillippe Grillot

Somewhere, Over ‘In Rainbows’

Most folks are looking this gift horse squarely in the mouth, with a steely gaze that says it’s time to make glue.

For every delighted fan there appear to be many more reports of spam, leaving Apple to back peddle somewhat and announce a U2 removal tool to rid iTunes accounts of the intruding album. While a part of me feels a pang of sympathy for a renowned band trying to find its way into the ears of a new audience, my remainder screams “messiah marketing gone too far.”

And the cynical side would be right.

For all those who thought the pay what you want experiment of Radiohead’s “In Rainbows” undermined the value of music, this is your new low; an album so stripped of its inherent value that it achieves junk mail status to the majority of recipients. Of course U2 got paid for the whole stunt by Apple, and their back catalog has seen the expected bump in sales on iTunes as a result, but for the wider sphere of artists the album as a piece of work worth paying for has perhaps heard its final death knell.

If one of the most recognized bands in the world is giving a full set away, why would anyone pay for a smaller band’s collection of songs?

Well some will, and they will always form the core of any artist’s fan base, but they’re no longer the norm and this isn’t a new situation.

The current climate has been building for years, as digital downloads liberated the single and unlimited streaming services made playlists the go-to tool for extended listening sessions. The value of music hasn’t so much been decimated as it has redistributed, meaning that artists need to know where to look to soak up new revenue streams.

Look to online ads. Look to associations with other creative partners. Just don’t look to the older artists desperately trying to squeeze blood from a stone.

 

Push No More

The Music Wealth GapIf any doubt remained that music can no longer be battering rammed into the listener’s brain, this should extinguish it. We’re overwhelmed by choice and underserved by time, leaving little opportunity to sample fresh songs and only the slightest space to pull in the new that we love.

With push marketing having run its course for all but the biggest artists, smaller acts are left to navigate the more complex world of pull marketing; being so alluring and/or ubiquitous that the music becomes unavoidable. It’s back to classic word of mouth marketing, the subtle art of being everywhere without being intentionally in your face.

The rules of U2 – and Beyonce and Led Zeppelin and Jay Z before them – are not those of today’s rising artists.

The game has changed and these acts are playing their last few hands before slipping out of the popular spotlight. There won’t be another flash holiday release, because it’s been done. And Samsung won’t stump up another $5 million to release an album on its newest device, because that’s been done as well. And none of these tactics matter to the little guy anyway, because they can’t be replicated at any level other than superstardom.

When your local band releases a surprise album, the only surprising element is that they expected anyone other than hardcore fans to pay attention. With the best will in the world, and a burning desire to see new bands succeed: We. Have. No. Time.

Unless you come highly recommended, of course. If we trust the source or catch your creativity ourselves, then you’ve made the breakthrough. That means making your music available and ready to listen when a potential new fan finally comes calling. Be everywhere, be engaging, and be on the radar of influencers who make it their business to spread new songs that they love.

Most importantly, it means not pushing harder every time like the legacy artists you’ll never emulate, but instead being everywhere and inching into our ears with each subsequent spin.

Let the listener find you and be eager to explore every avenue that you’ve made available, audio, video, and any other medium you can exploit. The fan relationship will be all the better for it, and no-one will be forced to develop an app specifically to get you out of my music library.

Led Zep, Beyoncé, and Why Neither’s News Matters to Independent Musicians

In short, they’re big news, yet old news.

They made their names at a time when the game was completely different and can trade off their superstar status until they’re gone. How many up and coming indie musicians can say the same?

Fanfare vs. No Fair

Jimmy Page playing guitar
Image Credit: Dina Regine

Led Zeppelin  unleashed their back catalog on Spotify, cue trumpets.

Finally, one of the biggest rock bands ever is available to the hundreds of thousands of fans who use the streaming service, love the band, but previously had to dig out some physical release to listen to them. No new music is required to make this announcement worthwhile, as the triumph of having Zeppelin’s entire discography at the click of a button, at home and on-the-go, is enough to release a wave of pent up frustration at that previously limited access.

This simply doesn’t exist for releases by newer independent artists, whose work is cast into the vast archives of the streaming services. There they compete for listening time with other new releases by better known artists, not to mention the inimitable discographies of music legends. No fair, indeed.

Note that there are only now a few holdouts in the streaming space. They generally fall into one of two camps; classic acts still wringing the last few quid from physical music formats, and more contemporary acts finding fault with the payment model of Spotify and its ilk. Both have valid arguments, but the former will dry up within the next few years, as CD revenues become negligible and vinyl continues to occupy the same specialist niche it has comfortably maintained for years (thank goodness). And when the likes of the Beatles, AC/DC, and Garth Brooks finally flip that switch, the fanfare will be there for them too, as will a significant royalty check from the burst of listeners pouring over their respective canons.

This will not – and may never – be the case for independent musicians on their way up.

Why would it? Even the most hotly anticipated new releases barely make a dent on mainstream media in the current climate of music, meaning there is no rush to listen. Release dates matter less and less, albums are increasingly difficult to market as an overall listening proposition, and it’s the individual tracks, more than ever, that drive a deeper dive into a new artist’s work. Having an unexpected hit, a la Lorde with ‘Royals’, is a more likely route to some form of wider recognition.

Now, on the subject of surprises…

Beyoncé Is the Exception, Not the Rule

Beyonce silhouette
Image Credit: José Goulão

The superstar dropped a surprise album last week, cue a flock of media attention.

Unlike Led Zep, a new release was indeed the draw here (except for Target, who have thrown their toys out of the pram). Add to that the masterful avoidance of leaked material, or any benefit from pre-release hype, and surely we have a marketing master class? Sure, but only for Beyoncé and, perhaps, others with her level of recognition and guaranteed media attention.

Again, there are few examples of this in the current ranks of rising artists and certainly none who could pull it off without a series of previous successes. Beyoncé built her reputation before the collapse of album sales and relied on plenty of long-term, expensive marketing campaigns for much of the discography that precedes her latest effort. Independent musicians struggle every day to get their releases, surprise or otherwise, noticed by even the smallest of music blogs.

What hope is there of attracting any sort of fervor to a release by a relatively unknown indie act? Next to none, unfortunately. Or perhaps it’s a good thing, as we’re forced back again to the crux of the matter; crafting a career in music based on longevity, rather than sudden hype or momentary gimmicks.

Where to Look for Lessons in Music Marketing

Not up, but around.

The superstars and classic acts have already built their base and have full marketing teams at their bidding to exploit it effectively. You, the independent musicians doing it on your own time, do not. But when you see those of a similar size and stature around you gaining attention and beginning to break out, ask yourself what it is they’re doing that you can replicate and improve upon by making it your own.

And while you’re looking around, don’t forget to think about how to distinguish yourself. What is everyone doing that causes them to blend together, to . As much as you want to eschew short term gimmicks, don’t overlook the value of having a hook. Something as simple as the way you look or the places you play may be enough to set you apart, if not on first impression then after listeners have multiple encounters with your music.

In the end, perhaps the one thing we can learn from the superstars is that independent acts can’t achieve that single, huge fanfare for attention. The good news is that a slower development of several smaller, noteworthy moments can build to a crescendo of similar proportions, while at the same time making  for a more sustainable career than any overnight superstardom would permit.